Piezo vs LRA vs ERM: How to Choose a Haptic Actuator

LRA-vs-ERM-vs-PIEZO_900x-1

 Piezo, LRA and ERM actuators are the three main ways to create haptic feedback in electronics. ERMs are low-cost motors suited to simple alerts. LRAs deliver crisper vibration near a single resonant frequency and dominate smartphone notifications. Piezo actuators respond fastest, cover the widest frequency range and keep feedback local, but require a high-voltage driver. 


Key Takeaways

  • ERM, LRA and piezo actuators are the three main haptic technologies in consumer electronics.
  • An LRA needs about 25 ms to reach its resonant frequency, which users feel as a slight lag.
  • A piezo actuator responds within 0.3 to 1.5 ms, depending on the driver.
  • Piezo actuators deliver feedback under the finger. ERMs and LRAs vibrate the whole device.
  • Piezo actuators need a dedicated high-voltage driver, up to 190 Vpk-pk.

 



1. What is a haptic actuator?
DSC00169-1

A haptic actuator is a component that converts an electrical signal into motion the user can feel. It confirms a touch, signals an alert or simulates a texture.

Three technologies share the market.

An ERM (eccentric rotating mass) is a DC motor with an off-center weight that shakes the device as it spins. It is the oldest of the three and still the cheapest.

An LRA (linear resonant actuator) is a mass on a spring driven at its resonant frequency. Apple's Taptic Engine is the best-known LRA-type actuator. Texas Instruments' DRV2605 is a common driver for both ERM and LRA actuators (TI).

A piezo actuator is a ceramic element that bends when voltage is applied. The motion is small and fast, and it happens right where the actuator sits. TDK's PowerHap line is one example of piezo actuators built for haptics (Power Systems Design). The effect behind it is piezoelectricity, and the broader field is haptic technology.



  
2. Haptic actuators compared: ERM vs LRA vs piezo

 The three actuators differ most in two places: how fast the user feels the feedback, and where on the device they feel it. 

Criterion ERM LRA Piezo
How it works A DC motor spins an off-center mass A mass on a spring vibrates at its resonant frequency A ceramic element deforms when voltage is applied
Delay before the user feels feedback Slowest of the three About 25 ms to reach its resonant frequency, felt as a slight lag 0.3 to 1.5 ms, set by the driver start-up time; the actuator responds as soon as it is driven
Frequency range Coupled to amplitude Narrow band around resonance About 1 to 400 Hz
Where the user feels it Whole device Whole device Under the finger
Force sensing No No Possible; the actuator can act as the sensor
Drive voltage 1 to 5 V DC About 2 Vrms High voltage, up to 190 Vpk-pk
Form factor Small motor Bulkier module with a moving mass Thin, sits directly under the touch surface
Main limitation Slow and imprecise; frequency and strength cannot be set separately One efficient frequency, so clicks feel like a buzz Needs a dedicated high-voltage driver; the feel depends on how the actuator is mounted
Typical use Low-cost devices, simple alerts Smartphone notifications Trackpads, solid-state buttons, wearables

 Delays: Boréas bench measurements. Piezo values use a TDK PowerHap 2.5G actuator. ERM and LRA drive voltages and LRA resonance: Texas Instruments.  Texas Instruments.

The LRA delay is easy to miss on a spec sheet and easy to feel in the hand. The actuator has to build up to its resonant frequency before the vibration reaches full strength. During those 25 ms or so, the user has already pressed and is waiting.


3.  Can you build a solid-state button with an LRA? 
  Yes, if you accept that the vibration spreads through the whole hand.

Apple's Camera Control on the iPhone 16 is one example of this hybrid approach. It combines a mechanical switch for the full press, a force sensor and a capacitive surface, and it uses the phone's Taptic Engine for the light press that locks focus (TechRadar). Other architectures are possible.

Because an LRA moves the whole phone, Apple keeps that light-press vibration very weak. It stays discreet. Users can still tell the control does not feel like a normal button, and reviewers have questioned how often people use it (9to5Mac).

Oppo followed with a pressure-sensitive camera control on its Find X8 series in 2024 (9to5Google) and kept it on the Find X9 Pro (GSMArena).

With a piezo actuator placed directly under the button, the feedback comes from the point of contact. Its waveform can also change with each press level, so a light press and a full press can feel different.

4. How to choose a haptic actuator

  1. Define the job: alert or click. If the device only needs notifications, such as an incoming call or a timer, an ERM or an LRA is enough. If users press, slide or click, the feedback has to confirm an action.
  2. Decide where the user should feel it. Whole-device vibration works in a pocket or on a wrist. A button on the edge of a phone or on the temple of a pair of glasses is different. The feedback has to stay at the button, without shaking the device or the user's face. That points to a piezo actuator.
  3. Check responsiveness. A click has to arrive with the press. An LRA needs about 25 ms to reach its resonant frequency, which users feel as a slight lag. On a trackpad, that ramp-up makes the surface feel less responsive, even when the vibration feels local. A piezo actuator responds within 0.3 to 1.5 ms, depending on the driver.
  4. Check the space available. Piezo actuators and their drivers fit where an LRA cannot, down to the temple of a pair of glasses. The Boréas BOS1921 driver comes in a 2.1 x 1.7 mm package.
  5. Plan the driver and the power budget. A piezo actuator needs a dedicated high-voltage driver. That driver sets both start-up time and power consumption.


Same actuator, different driver

The last step deserves numbers. We drove the same TDK PowerHap 2.5G piezo actuator with a competing driver and with a Boréas CapDrive driver.

  Piezo + competing driver Piezo + CapDrive driver
Start-up time 1.5 ms 0.3 ms
Power consumption Medium Low, up to 10 times lower
Integrated force sensing No Yes
Driver footprint Small Miniature

Source: Boréas bench measurements, same actuator for both drivers.

The actuator did not change. The driver cut the start-up time by a factor of five and the power by up to ten. CapDrive gets there by recovering the energy stored in the piezo actuator after each click instead of dissipating it. The CapDrive article explains how.


5. Frequently asked questions

Is piezo haptic feedback better than an LRA? For clicks and buttons, usually yes. A piezo actuator responds within 0.3 to 1.5 ms and can keep the feedback under the finger. For simple notifications, an LRA is often enough and simpler to integrate, since it runs from a low-voltage driver.

Can you use an LRA for a solid-state button? Yes, if you accept that the vibration spreads through the whole hand. An LRA paired with a capacitive or force-sensing surface can confirm presses without moving parts. Apple's iPhone Camera Control is one example of a hybrid design, combining a mechanical switch, sensors and an LRA, but other architectures are possible.

Are ERM motors still used in new products? Yes, mainly in low-cost devices and simple alerts. ERMs still appear in handheld tools, scanners, medical instruments, GPS trackers and in-car alerts (Precision Microdrives). They are cheap and easy to drive, but slow to start and stop, and their frequency and strength cannot be set separately.

Why does an LRA click feel like a buzz? Because an LRA works at a single resonant frequency and needs about 25 ms to reach it. Users feel a short lag, then a vibration that spreads across the device. A sharp click needs a fast start, a fast stop and a shaped waveform, which a piezo actuator can deliver.

Do haptic trackpads use LRA or piezo actuators? Both are used. In both cases the touch surface itself moves, so the feedback can feel local. The difference shows in responsiveness: the LRA ramp-up time can make the surface feel slightly slower than a piezo design. A piezo trackpad can also use its actuators to measure how hard the user presses.

 

6. Glossary

  • Resonant frequency: the single frequency at which an LRA vibrates efficiently.
  • Localized haptics: feedback felt only where the finger touches, not across the whole device.
  • Haptic driver: the chip that turns a digital command into the signal that moves the actuator.
  • Solid-state button: a button with no moving parts that uses an actuator to simulate a click.

7. Related reading

 

8. Next steps

 

Author

Marc-André Morin, Boréas Technologies. 

 

 

How to select the right piezo driver and actuator combination

Leave a comment